Such a timely topic for me.
I had three rings - engagement, wedding, and anniversary. Since DDay, I've only worn my engagement ring because the other two were tainted.
We went camping last weekend, and I put my engagement ring on the straw of my tumbler when we went to bed. I forgot about it and now have no idea where it is. I'm not really upset about it, and told my H that it was missing, and he said, "I don't like that ring anyway. I messed that all up." Dude! I don't either!
He bought it himself without getting my input about what I might want, and it's TOTALLY not my style. I like simple, clean lines, and it was very... 1987. He went through a huge ordeal trying to get the funds to buy it before his leave was over, and then he drove me to the jewelry store to pick it up and proposed right there at the counter in front of the saleswoman. He's a romantic guy, and that was not romantic.
Anyway - it seems to be gone, and neither of us really care all that much. It really feels like big, good changes are happening in life right now, and maybe it was time for a symbol of the old life to take its leave. If it turns up, cool. If it doesn't, that's alright too.
When we got married, we were young and very broke, and he traded a shotgun for two gold rings, a toaster, and some silverware. Not even kidding. His Marine buddy was getting a divorce, and we put his old, tainted rings on our fingers. When we got mine resized, it warped and turned ugly. Right after DDay, I took mine off and haven't worn it since. He crushed his in a press at work, carried it in his wallet while we were separated, and then symbolically threw it in the lake on our first anniversary after we started R. I replaced his with a titanium band. It was too large, so we bought the same ring again a size smaller, and he wears one on each hand. He loves his rings.
"I'm guilty of having an affair so I am making myself feel better" ring.
I got one of those, too. His first A was right before he deployed to Desert Storm. When he came home almost a year later, he spent a good chunk of the savings I had amassed in his absence (he's a spendthrift and I'm a saver) to buy an eternity ring. It's so very tainted, and has sat in my jewelry box since DDay.
I've tried out other rings over the years, but nothing seems quite right. An old wedding band of my dad's. A gorgeous 14 carat emerald cut amethyst on a simple gold band that I love, but that H doesn't like on that particular finger. I'm not sure what I want. I'm good with simple and inexpensive. Hell, I'm good with CZ. I don't care all that much. Just not sure what I want...