The tragic thing some us see is that your Hopium addition could very well result in an unsuccessful R - the very thing you’re working so hard for. Refusing to set expectations, boundaries, and consequences will sadly drive your W away, as it erodes any respect she had for you. Women are NOT drawn to men they don’t respect.
Yikes! An unsuccessful R! Oh, the horror, the horror. Most of us recover from unsuccessful Rs - and jumping to D when you're undecided is almost a surefire way of preventing a successful R.
wjb, my reco to you (and to every BS) is to take control of your life and to decide on your own timeline. I believe decisions come from heart, head, and gut. IMO, they'll align eventually. Once they do align, you'll know. That's the best time to decide.
You may get fed-up with your W's behavior before November. That's fine. You may want to gather more data. That's probably fine. Your W may start showing consistent remorse and make R a real possibility. That's fine. Right now you have conflicting data, and you want R. I do not see the problem in waiting until November - that's a very brief period in most people's lives.
I'm a bit concerned that your IC focuses on your W. Is he also helping you with your feelings and your wants?
No amount of counseling in the world is going to help your wife love you and respect you as you deserve to be loved and respected.
First, this betrays a clear misunderstanding of the potential results of therapy. We have a lot of control over ourselves. If Mrs. Brennan makes loving and respecting wjb a goal of her therapy, and if the therapist is competent, she'll end up loving and respecting wjb. If she focuses on learning to love herself, she may end up loving and respecting wjb; she'll almost definitely end up respecting him.
There are so many variables involved in therapy that it's impossible to predict the results from a few posts on an anonymous forum. If you think you know and/or if you think you can predict someone else's future, you're lying to yourself.
D is the one surefire way out of infidelity,
Yu seem to be missing the most important aspect of 'getting out of infidelity'. You don't just get out of a sitch - you replace one sitch with another. More important than getting out of infidelity is choosing what you get into.
Forcing yourself to choose one of a number of long-term things with unknown results isn't likely to lead to a happy, productive life.
I can't help thinking that the 'D is always right' comes from fear and a belief that one isn't strong enough to do the thinking and feeling necessary to deal with being a BS. I can't help thinking that it comes from a desire for an easy way out.
There is no easy way out of infidelity.
You can't heal without resolving the pain of being betrayed (or betraying, for that matter).
There is no one size fits all.
...attempting R in the meanwhile is a low-percentage move that involves years of pain and frustration quite possibly wasted representing years of your life that you will never get back....
First, you do not know the probability of success of R ... or of D.
More important, whatever you do, if you don't resolve the anger, grief, fear, and shame of being betrayed, you'll endure years of pain and frustration quite possibly wasting years of your life that you will never get back whether you D or R.
But Brennan, take no shit and don’t feel like it’s your failure of you decide to bail before the time frame is up. There are things here that are positive- she told him the AP broke no contact, she must be being honest about where she is on things because he knows she is still conflicted so she must not be lying or trying to pretend.
...you cannot counsel or talk your WW back into treating you as her H and putting you first.
Yes. R will not succeed unless your W chooses to do the necessary work. My reco is to leave her alone to make her choice as freely as possible. Just make sure you know R is a lot more than just going NC.
You do not want to enter R with a WS who is manipulated into R. They'll resent it, and R doesn't work when one partner resents the other.
*****
Are you using 'limerence' as an excuse or as an explanation? Your W cheated. That brings up feelings in you no matter why she cheated. It's important that you don't discount your own pain. BTDT.
And don't discount limerence. Your W presumably lit up when she saw you at one time, maybe - I hope - for a long time. Now she may have lit up when she saw om. She wanted to be with him. You have to live with that, but you don't have to live with her.
Meanwhile, if you haven't already read it, I recommend Love and Limerence by Dorothy Tannov. She coined the term.
*****
For the record, I almost automatically saw my W's A as a symptom of an emotional disease. I almost automatically took her A as her issue, because I was confident she would have had a hard time imagining a better H than I was (which was a little weird because some of our differences hurt). She couldn't eat or sleep during the A. On d-day, I learned why she was so fucked up, and it seemed clear to me that ending the A (which she had decided to do in the hours before she revealed the A, would be a big step in 'curing' the 'disease'. (I use quotes, because the terms are metaphorical.)
Ask yourself how you view her A. Some ways of seeing and A are conducive to R; some, conducive to D. Don't force it - just look inside for the metaphor that works for you. The answers you get are indicators of what you really want.